Tuesday, July 26, 2011

Homemade Cream Cheese

Homemade Cream Cheese

Fresh, creamy and slightly tangy - who knew cream cheese could be this good?

There are certain things we almost always keep on hand and try to make more of as soon as we run out. While Mike is in charge of keeping us supplied with his Taco Shop Hot Sauce, I'm in charge of the cream cheese. I've been making it for a few years now, and have gradually settled on a technique that's easy, reliable and delicious.

All you have to do is:

  1. Add starter culture and rennet to room temperature milk and cream.
  2. Let it sit for a day.
  3. Drain the curds in fine cheese cloth for another day.
  4. Add salt and flavorings (optional).
  5. Eat and enjoy!

Here it is after the first step - the mesophilic starter culture acidifies the milk allowing the rennet to do its magic and turn the milk into a soft gel. It's been sitting on the counter top for about 24 hours.

Homemade Cream Cheese

Next put a strainer lined with dampened cheese cloth into the sink and gently scoop in the curds. The cheese is set up almost like a yogurt at this point.

Homemade Cream Cheese

The fine cheese cloth (butter muslin) allows the solids to firm up while the whey drains away. Don't use regular cheese cloth - the weave is too loose.

Homemade Cream Cheese

Hang it up and let it drain another 18-24 hours...

Homemade Cream Cheese

Now it's cream cheese! All that's left is to add a little salt. For variety you can add fresh herbs or garlic and black pepper or whatever you choose.

Homemade Cream Cheese

I've tried other recipes which use a lot more cream and were often heated on the stove top, but they were all too solid and grainy. This one on the other hand is light and creamy - almost the texture of whipped cream when it's just made - and it sets up nicely once cooled.

Homemade Cream Cheese

We have found cream cheese to be surprisingly versatile as an ingredient in the kitchen. We often use it in place of cream, sour cream, crème fraiche or even buttermilk. It adds a tangy richness to soups, and Mike makes a great mushroom sauce with it.

Oh, and it's not bad on a homemade bagel, either...

Simple Cream Cheese

This simple cream cheese has an appealing fresh, slightly tangy flavor and it’s super easy to make.

Important: make sure your milk and cream are pasteurized and not ultra-pasteurized. If you can’t find regular pasteurized cream, decrease the milk by a cup and use 2 cups of pasteurized half-and-half instead of the cream.

1 cup heavy cream (pasteurized, but not ultra-pasteurized)
1/2 gallon whole milk (pasteurized, but not ultra-pasteurized)
1 packet mesophilic direct-set starter (1/4 t)
4 drops liquid rennet
1- 1 ½ teaspoons Morton's kosher salt ( ½ - ¾ t if using regular table salt)

Stir together the milk and cream, then let it come to room temp: leave it in a warm place a few hours, or put it on the stove top on very low, or put it into a barely warm turned-off oven (do not microwave).

Sprinkle the mesophilic starter over the milk, let it sit a couple minutes, and then stir it in gently, but thoroughly. Add the rennet and stir another 60 seconds. Cover and let sit 18-24 hours.

Gently ladle the curds into a colander lined with fine cheese cloth -- I like to do this over a large bowl. Carefully lift the corners of the cheese cloth and tie them together. Hang from a cupboard knob or other convenient place and place a bowl beneath to catch the drips. Leave alone for 12-24 hours. The longer you wait, the stiffer the cheese will be.

Turn the cream cheese into a bowl and use a wooden spoon to mix in the salt. (Note - the salt will dissolve and become more uniform tasting after the cheese has rested for a few hours.) If you want to add flavorings (herbs, garlic, pepper, fruit) to portions of the cream cheese it's easiest to that now while it’s warm. Or it's great plain too.


  1. A special post as usual. I wish we lived closer.

  2. Looks incredibly decadent, Sherry! Do you use the whey for anything?

  3. Hi Carol, Yeah the cheese tastes luscious, but it actually has less cream (fat) than a lot of versions. :-) Unfortunately I haven't found a good use for the whey yet. People often use it in baking, but I don't bake quite that much...

  4. Hi Sherry, I did a quick search and looks like it might be possible to make ricotta out of leftover whey. Now that sounds very interesting.

  5. Hi Carol, I've tried making ricotta with leftover whey from other cheeses (eg queso fresco or feta), but the yield was very small and the resulting cheese quite grainy (almost too much protein I think). It worked fairly well if you add additional fresh milk, though - the yield is higher and you still get the flavor boost from the culture. I haven't tried that method with the cream cheese whey. Maybe I will next time, since you've got me curious now.

  6. I have been wanting to make cheese, bit not able to find liquid rennet or the tablets (rennin tablets), any suggestions where it can be purchased? I have checked with a couple of health food stores, they don't have it. Any food chains. I don't have a clue

  7. Hi - Here in San Diego we can buy rennet (liquid and tablets) locally at Curds and Wine, but if you're not in SD I'm told it may be available at Whole Foods. Otherwise you can purchase it online -- before Curds and Wine opened up, I used Leeners.com, and you can get it here too.